Top Dependable Used Cars for 2024

Trustworthy Vehicles for Every Walk of Life

On the hunt for a pre-loved car to keep pace with your lifestyle? Perhaps you’re in search of a comfy daily ride for your commute, or a spacious family transporter for kid pick-ups and supermarket sweeps? From elegant four-doors to sporty hatches, at MotoPickers we know there’s a second-hand vehicle to fit your way of life.

So we’ve put together a roster of the MotoPickers Top 10 most trustworthy used cars for our 2024 shoppers. Our ranking leans on the reliability ratings from our trusted associates.

Acura TLX

Motopickers Rating 8.3/10

In the hunt for a chic midsize sedan that triggers a grin each time you hop in the driver’s seat? You might want to check out the 2021 Acura TLX. Its swanky exterior design packs a mighty punch, with two engine choices—a 2.0L turbo-four delivering 272 hp and a 3.0L turbo-six dishing out 355 hp.

The turbo-six comes standard on the sporty Type S variant, which also sports 20-inch wheels, Brembo™ performance brakes, and adjustable suspension (in 2021 models). For those laid-back drives to the office, the 2021 TLX comes fitted with a host of handy driver-assist features as standard—think forward collision alert, lane assist, and adaptive cruise control.

Lexus ES 300h

Motopickers Rating 8.3/10

The 2019-2021 Lexus ES 300h is more than just a midsize luxury sedan—it’s a journey of smooth drives and generous cabin comfort, perfect for both daily runs and long-haul trips. Its standard powerplant is a 2.5L four-cylinder engine, paired with an electric motor, which together offer a nifty EPA-estimated 44 mpg combined fuel economy on 2019-2021 variants.

Even on extended trips, you can look forward to various indulgences; base models from 2019-2021 come with goodies like a sunroof and dual-zone automatic climate control. Shooting for the stars? The 2019-2021 Ultra Luxury edition comes packed with features like a hands-free trunk, premium leather seats, and an automatic rear sunshade.

Honda CR-Z

Motopickers Rating 7.2/10

If you’ve dreamt of a compact car that marries practicality with a cool two-door coupe style, the CR-Z is one to go for. Its swooping lines are sure to draw second looks, and it’s a top option when it comes to stylish city driving. Models from 2016 onwards come kitted out with a hybrid powertrain that combines a 1.5L four-cylinder motor with an electric unit.

Tied to a continuously variable automatic transmission, it offers an outstanding EPA-estimated fuel economy of 36 mpg combined. The interior doesn’t disappoint either: standard equipment in even the base LX models includes cruise control, automatic climate control, and a rearview camera.

Toyota Camry

Motopickers Rating 8/10

The 2018-2021 Toyota Camry strikes a bold pose as a midsize sedan, featuring an expansive interior with ample space—42.1 inches of front seat legroom, 38 inches in the rear, and a roomy 15.1 cu-ft trunk for luggage. The 2018-2021 models come in two engine varieties. The standard offering is a thrifty 2.5L four-cylinder engine, boasting an EPA-estimated fuel economy of 34 mpg combined.

If you want to jazz up your ride, choose the 3.5L V6 engine, boasting 301 horsepower and 267 lb-ft of torque. Plus, the 2020-2021 models introduce the sporty TRD trim, featuring a sports exhaust, aerodynamic body kit, and a sport-tuned suspension. This is a quality offering that will last you well for years.

Toyota Corolla

Motopickers Rating 8/10

The crowd-favourite Toyota Corolla got a complete overhaul in 2020, giving this compact sedan a significant upgrade. The 2020-2021 models boast sleek lines, two engine choices, and a laundry list of standard features that include driver assistance tech.

Think forward collision mitigation, lane departure warning, and adaptive cruise control lined up for you. The roomy interior of this sedan model accommodates five comfortably, with over 40 inches of legroom in both the front and rear on the 2020-2021 models. And with a generous 13.1 cu-ft of trunk space, there’s ample room for shopping bags or luggage.

Lexus CT 200h

Motopickers Rating 8/10

Craving a touch of luxury in your hatchback choice? Look no further than the suave, smooth-riding and classy Lexus CT 200h. All models from 2017 onwards feature a hybrid powerhouse, merging a 1.8L four-cylinder petrol engine with a couple of electric motors to clock an EPA-estimated 42 mpg combined. Its nimble handling also makes city driving a total breeze.

On the inside, things notch up—room for five, a generous 14.3 cu-ft cargo area behind the rear seats, and a host of standard perks like dual-zone automatic climate control, polished vinyl upholstery, and split-folding rear seats (in the 2017 models).

Toyota Yaris

Motopickers Rating 7.7/10

When it comes to mastering city driving, the Toyota Yaris is a top contender. With its chic hatchback style and sprightly handling, it’s a pro for maneuvering busy streets. The 1.5L four-cylinder engine under its hood helps the 2019-2020 models clinch a commendable EPA-estimated fuel economy of 35 mpg combined when married to a six-speed automatic gearbox.

High-end XLE variants from 2019-2020 step up the game with perks like auto LED headlights and wipers, automatic climate control, faux leather seats, and dual driving modes—Normal and Sport—upping the driving experience.

Toyota Yaris iA

Motopickers Rating 7.5/10

Keen on blending the agility of a subcompact with the flair of a sedan? Say hello to the Toyota Yaris iA—an elegant sedan variant of the classic Yaris, co-created and developed by Mazda. The 2017-2018 models sport a standard 1.5L four-cylinder engine which, when mated to a six-speed automatic transmission, achieves an EPA-estimated fuel economy of 35 mpg combined.

The sedan layout gifts you ample cabin space, alongside a robust 13.5 cu-ft cargo area behind the rear seats. Every 2017-2018 Yaris iA also comes fitted with perks like a low-speed forward collision alert system, full power accessories, and a 60/40 split rear seat that can fold down.

Toyota Prius c

Motopickers Rating 7.6/10

Zeroing in on a flexible used compact hatchback? Then the Toyota Prius C is worth a look. All 2017-2019 models house a 1.5L four-cylinder engine twinned with an electric motor—it easily nails an EPA-estimated 46 mpg combined.

Plus, with a generous 17.1 cu-ft cargo area behind the rear seats, it’s a champ at handling weekly supermarket hauls. It earns serious bonus points for handy standard features like auto climate control and a 6.1-inch voice-command-enabled touchscreen display across all 2017-2019 Prius C trims.

Lexus ES350

Motopickers Rating 8.5/10

Craving opulence and unrivaled comfort in your everyday ride? Cast your eyes on the Lexus ES 350—a swanky midsize sedan that combines sleek exterior styling with roomy interiors. The 2019-2020 models comfortably seat five, providing ample legroom, with 42.4 inches up front and 39.2 inches in the back.

Plus, the array of standard luxuries on all 2019-2021 models delivers a first-rate experience on the go. From dual-zone automatic climate control, a sunroof, to power-adjustable front seats, every mile in the Lexus ES 350 is set to spoil you and your riders.